The Nodder Price Guide
Brought to you by
The Nodder
Exchange
Years produced - 1961-1963
Details - 6.5" high on white base
Hat styles - (2) Swirl, and Sideways Hat
Mascots -
Braves, Cards, Cubs, Indians, Orioles, Pirates,
Reds, Tigers
Variations - Anaheim Angels, Colt 45
Blue Uniform, Dodgers and Giants decals, Mays and Mantle, Mets.
Prices Updated 2018
Dolls priced in 3 Grades: NrMt/Mt,
NrMt and EX+. Lesser condition examples would sell for less. (See the Condition
Guide for explanations)
Rarity index - 10 rarest, 1 easiest to find.
Gem Dolls (Like new colors and shine) normally go for more.
Gem mint looking restored dolls normally go for roughly the same as NrMt
examples, often more.
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Angels | Anaheim | 06 | 120-140 | 175-200 | 200-250 | Paper label was put over the LA base decal when they were planning their move to Anaheim. LA on hat was usually colored in with blue also. Same description as the LA doll below but tougher to find. | |
Angels | LA | 04 | 75-100 | 100-125 | 125-175 | Fairly common
doll, almost always comes in the sideways hat style. Usually rather dull, hard to find with gem colors and shine. |
|
Athletics |
KC |
05 | 90-120 | 125-175 | 175-225 | One of the few White Bases that come with a chest decal, not embossed. Holding bat, can come with or without pinstripes. | |
Braves | Milwaukee | 6 | 150-200 | 225-250 | 250-300 | High end examples do very well. |
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Cardinals | St Louis | 7 | 200-225 | 300-350 | 375-450 | One of the most repaired (touched up) dolls around. They are hard to come by in any condition but almost impossible in NrMt/Mt. Look very closely at the sharply pointed rear feathers for touchups. | |
Colt 45 | Houston | 6 | 100-125 | 125-150 | 150-200 | Both Colt 45 dolls come with or without the crossed pistol decals on hat and base, small premium for dolls with decals. Cowboy hat almost always has erratic paint strokes. White jersey has become a bit tough to find lately. | |
Colt 45 Blue Jersey | Houston | 6 | 300-350 | 425-500 | 500-750 | First run of Colt 45 dolls came with an all blue uniform. Quite a few have popped up but still a very desirable doll. | |
Cubs | Chicago | 6 | 150-200 | 225-300 | 375-425 | Pretty tough doll, hard to find a bright one as body paint is normally toned a bit. | |
Dodgers | LA | 5 | 80-100 | 125-150 | 175-200 | Almost always
holding a ball, I've only had one holding a bat. |
|
Dodgers Decal | LA | 7 | 100-140 | 150-200 | 200-250 | Comes with a small chest decal rather than the embossed logo. Pretty tough variation. | |
Giants | SF | 7 | 125-150 | 175-250 | 350-400 | Very, very tough doll to find in NrMt/Mt condition. Black hat, chest and hat decals, always seem to have problems. | |
Giants Decal | SF | 7 | 120-150 | 225-250 | 300-350 | Comes with a small chest decal rather than the embossed logo. Pretty tough variation. |
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Indians | Cleveland | 5 | 200-250 | 250-300 | 350-400 | Often restored, hard to find a top original doll. | |
Mets | NY | 6 | 125-150 | 150-175 | 200-250 | Very condition sensitive doll, pretty tough in any condition but especially so in higher grades. | |
Mets Blue Shoes | NY | 6 | 125-150 | 175-225 | 250-300 | Neat variation with the blue shoes. Chest decal can vary in size. | |
Mets Unique Face | NY | 10 | 150-200 | 200-225 | 225-400 | Previously this style face was only known with the Senators. Quite rare, I've only seen a few. | |
Orioles | Baltimore | 7 | 150-200 | 225-300 | 350-425 | Head is a bit smaller than the original Color Base Oriole. Has become a tough doll to find. | |
Phillies | Philadelphia | 5 | 100-125 | 140-180 | 180-250 | Nice doll, fairly available for a white base. |
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Pirates | Pittsburgh | 7 | 150-180 | 200-250 | 250-400 | Still very difficult and probably the key to the set. | |
Reds | Cincinnati | 6 | 100-150 | 150-225 | 200-350 | Tough doll, very difficult to find with a white head that is not heavily shellacked. | |
Red Sox | Boston | 5 | 100-125 | 125-175 | 175-250 | Comes with a decal, not embossed. | |
Senators | Washington | 5 | 100-125 | 150-225 | 225-300 | About the middle of the road for this set. | |
Senators (Unique Face) |
Washington | 5 | 100-125 | 150-225 | 225-300 | For some reason, the Senator White Base was also made with this unique face, different from any other mold made. Recently saw a Mets example in this face, don't know of any others. |
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Tigers | Detroit | 5 | 100-130 | 160-240 | 200-350 | Nicks to ears often a problem. Beautiful looking doll in "Gem" condition. Hard to find with a white body. | |
Twins | Minnesota | 7 | 100-120 | 150-200 | 250-400 | I find this to be a very tough doll to find in any condition. Has really dried up lately. | |
Twins | Minneapolis | 10 | ? | ? | $4000+ | Super rare variation, I've only had one ever. Went for over $4000 in 2013. | |
White Sox | Chicago | 4 | 80-100 | 120-160 | 175-225 | Comes around often, however pretty tough to find with bright colors and shine. |
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Yankees | NY | 4 | 90-125 | 140-180 | 200-250 | Comes with or without pinstripes. Fairly available but still pretty popular. | |
Yankees Elbows | NY | 5 | 100-130 | 150-200 | 225-350 | Tougher Yankee variation although more have shown up recently. | |
Willie Mays | SF | 5 | 175-200 | 250-300 | 300-450 |
The original dark face Mays was issued with the
White Base set. Not rare but very hard to find in top condition,
particularly the chest decal. Name is misspelled on the base. |
|
Willie Mays Light Face | SF | 5 | 175-200 | 225-300 | 300-450 | This doll was actually reissued several years after the White Base set was produced, roughly 1966. Facial features almost look "Asian". I think there are fewer "light faces" out there but its easier to find these with "gem" qualities. |
Click to Enlarge | Nickname | City | Rarity | Ex+ | NrMt | NrMt/Mt | Comments |
Willie Mays Silver Sticker | SF | 9 | 500-700 | 700-900 | 1000-1200+ | Very rare doll that doesn't show up often. Only one I've ever had for sale went for $1183 in 2014. | |
Willie Mays Correct Signature | SF | 9 | 600-800 | 800-1200 | 1200-1500+ | Another rarity, this one has a correctly spelled Willie Mays on the base. As of the begonning of 2019 I've had this doll in auction twice, went for $1669 and $1173 in 2017 and 2018. | |
Mickey Mantle | NY | 4 | 200-275 | 300-350 | 500-600 | Original Mantle on a square base. Very popular doll. Many have been surfacing and prices have dropped somewhat. A true "Mint" Mantle is tough to come by, most being sold as such have been restored.. Be very careful. Prices do not include the box. | |
Mickey Mantle Round Base | NY | 5 | 250-300 | 300-375 | 500-600 | Like the Mays light face, this is the reissued Mantle from 1966. Comes on a round base with wide shoulders. Often referred to as the "Muscles" variation. Rarer then the original Mantle. A true "Mint" Mantle is tough to come by, most being sold as such have been restored.. Be very careful. Prices do not include the box. |
White Base Notes:
This is the first Japan set that featured all 20 teams of the era (Mets and Colt 45's entered the league in 1962) and appears to have been a big improvement over the 1961 Color Base set. Nice quality overall, not as bright and colorful as the later Green Base set however its much nicer overall than the Gold Base. Two new head styles, the intro of the "mascot" heads, and the inclusion of base decals was a welcome improvement on the Color Base series. As mentioned above, the original first run included the custom illustrated boxes, I guess they realized quickly that it would be a lot cheaper and more practical to stick them in generic boxes with a stamp rather than have to mix and match the dolls with their correct box.
On a historical note, the players they chose to have their own dolls had great years in 1961, Maris and Mantle had their famous home run duel in 1961 and they were the talk of baseball. Willie Mays was also regarded by most as the best player of the era. (Ever, if you ask me). Clemente led the National league in batting with a .351 average and Latin born players were just starting to make there mark in the big leagues.. Frank Robinson, who was the NL MVP in 1961 and led his team to the World Series doesn't have a doll... I wonder if he was considered? Ditto Hank Aaron, Stan Musial, Sandy Koufax and Ernie Banks. Keep looking, you never know.
Mays and Mantle were the most popular players of the era, so it makes sense that both dolls were reissued later (about 1966) and were made in greater quantities than the Maris or the Clemente.
Also interesting is the Washington Senator doll. The Senators were a long time AL team that moved to Minnesota and became the Twins in 1961. It is assumed that the Color base Senator (which is extremely rare) represented that "Old" Senator team and was quickly replaced by the Twins doll which is very abundant. The "old" Senators were replaced immediately with a new expansion team (also called the Washington Senators, later the Texas Rangers). The White base Senator is really a doll representing one of the 2 new expansion teams. (LA Angels the other).
Speaking of the Angels, they planned to move from LA to Anaheim during the 1963 Season. The makers of Bobbing Heads responded by sticking paper labels, stars, or whatever else they could find on the LA white base dolls. Who wanted an LA doll if they were moving? Turns out the move took quite awhile, they played for several years in LA before finally moving and becoming the "California Angels". (See the California Angels Gold Base Doll). Its interesting to note that every once in awhile you can come across a Green Base doll with the Anaheim sticker. I guess things were still up in the air when they started the Green Base set...
Set includes a Spokane Indians Pacific Coast League doll. It's a Cleveland doll with a paper label. It's very rare but not all that sought after except for your serious collectors.
Colt 45 Blue Jersey variation was based on a real all Blue Uniform that the team wore on special occasions.